|
Donation/Premium |
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Survey |
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
 |
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
agnos Currently banned Captain

 Joined: Dec 28, 2006 Posts: 629 Location: Canada
|
Posted: Sat Jun 02, 2007 6:51 am Post subject: |
|
|
Sorry ZZ, that sounds like philosophy, not like religion. Religions have saviors(duh) or Gods. These people are not pushing any Gods. They were talking about God as a concept, not as a particular God. You are wrong. _________________ Humans are the most vicious of all animal species.
And we still prey(sic)...
Does anyone ever listen?
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
enegue
General
 Premium Member
 Joined: Aug 23, 2004 Posts: 3222 Location: Australia
|
Posted: Sat Jun 02, 2007 6:59 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Agnos wrote: | | ENLIL AND ENKI WERE GODS WHO WERE MORTAL ENEMIES. THEY EACH HAD THEIR OWN FOLLOWING. YHVH IS JUST THE ONE WHO HAD A BOOK WRITTEN ABOUT HIM, THAT SURVIVED. | Why did it survive? What is behind the persistence of scripture? You have no explanation. If the record of Yahweh survives, and spreads, and grows, then why didn't the others? Where are the numberless hymns, and poems, and essays, and treatises, and commentaries, analysing and disecting ENLIL's, and ENKI's record? They don't exist. Where are the enemies of ENLIL, and ENKI? They don't have any, because they don't exist. You exist, Agnos, and you have chosen at this point in time to pit yourself against the self-existent ONE. What makes you think you are up to the task? What are you presenting here that has not been presented before?
Cheers,
enegue
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
agnos Currently banned Captain

 Joined: Dec 28, 2006 Posts: 629 Location: Canada
|
Posted: Sat Jun 02, 2007 9:19 am Post subject: |
|
|
| enegue wrote: | | Agnos wrote: | | ENLIL AND ENKI WERE GODS WHO WERE MORTAL ENEMIES. THEY EACH HAD THEIR OWN FOLLOWING. YHVH IS JUST THE ONE WHO HAD A BOOK WRITTEN ABOUT HIM, THAT SURVIVED. | Why did it survive? What is behind the persistence of scripture? You have no explanation. If the record of Yahweh survives, and spreads, and grows, then why didn't the others? Where are the numberless hymns, and poems, and essays, and treatises, and commentaries, analysing and disecting ENLIL's, and ENKI's record? They don't exist. Where are the enemies of ENLIL, and ENKI? They don't have any, because they don't exist. You exist, Agnos, and you have chosen at this point in time to pit yourself against the self-existent ONE. What makes you think you are up to the task? What are you presenting here that has not been presented before?
Cheers,
enegue |
Enegue, it survived for the same reason Allah and Buddha survive today. Sure I have an explanation. And logically, even if I were not to have an explanation, it would still not mean that YHVH is real. Things just survive, others don't, it does not mean anything, beyond the fact that people talk about them. The plays of Shakespeare survived and will survive as long as humanity will exist, and that does not make Ariel real.
REALITY IS THAT WHICH CAN BE MADE EVIDENT AND ACTIVELY CAN BE OBSERVED INTERACTING WITH ANOTHER ELEMENT WITHIN REALITY.
THE GODS OF ALL CREEDS, INCLUDING CHRISTIANITY AND ISLAM FAIL THIS TEST.
There is nothing behind the Scriptures enegue, you just "want" it to be. It's inertia, it gives people hope, but it's false hope. Anyway, no one is gonna know the difference, one way or another, when we die, that's it...
What do you mean, didn't the others spread like the "record" of Yahweh? Islam is just fine, and unfortunately overtaking Christianity by leaps and bounds. It is the fastest growing religion. That's insane.
Enegue, please think, there is no "record" of YHVH. It's not the record of YHVH, as in YHVH is real, just because there is a book about the story. The Lord of the Rings movies are not "records" of anything, it's fiction, the characters are not real. Harry Potter is the same. The stories are not "records" of the life of Harry Potter actually existing, and HArry Potter is a fictional character. IT'S A BOOK. The God in this book only lives inside its pages and in the imaginations of the readers who believe the story inside. It does not mean it's really REAL. I told you, the Gods mentioned by Homer are not real, just because they are in his books and because Homer was pretty accurate historically, even more accurate than the Bible. Homer and others have been around and will be as long as humanity lasts, but the Gods and their atributes talked about in his writings are not real. You have allowed yourself to become irrational. You must snap out of it, and think outside the dogma for a while. Don't you see you cannot think objectively anymore? That should worry you.
What are you talking about? There is plenty of Sumerian and Babylonian religion floating around. The Bible also is nothing but a rehashing of those religions anyway. I told you, Christ/YHVH is a composite deity conglomerated through religious syncretism. Don't you find it suspect that the more evolved New Testament appeared around the great philosophy Renaissance brought about by the Greeks and the Romans? I told you, you cannot find one aspect from the supposed life of Christ that was not borrowed from an earlier religious mythology.
You are appealing to emotions enegue, that means your arguments are failing. Special pleading, the only desperate last limb. And you're going out on a limb here.
Your argument is so very flawed. Where are the enemies of YHVH? I don't see them either. I mean the legions of "fallen" angels, the "demons" that Jesus sent into pigs, the "demons" that you guys believe in and you think exist for real, where are those? Same as the enemies of Enlil or Enki. Where is Satan? Nowhere, it's an imaginary character.
Dude, your illogical logic scares me... What kind of thinking is this?
Enlil's and Enki's enemies do not exist, but Agnos exists, therefore YHVH must be the self-existing "One", (whatever that means), and therefore YHVH exists for real.
I have never heard anything more ridiculous. C'mon now enegue, snap out of it goddam* it, listen to what you're saying! This garbage has twisted your sense of logic and your train of thought is not rational anymore. You are clearly making implications that do not follow a logical train of argumentation.
The only thing I am pitting myself against is a fictional deity from a 2000 yrs old book, a composite entity from the ancient Pantheon of Gods. An entity about as weak and absent from reality as any other figment of imagination. All my ideas and questions are legitimate and genuine, and the fact that others may have asked some similar things does not necessarily detract from their power. I could turn that rationalization against you also: What are you presenting here that has not been presented before? But in your case, that detracts from your arguments, because you have nothing to show for this God. I have asked you to detail your supposed "relationship" to this entity, and you are unable to. Because you know that if you start inventing something, it will conflict with what other Christians are inventing and you will have made a fool of yourself.
I have also asked you how you know Jesus is "alive", and never heard from you again since on the matter. At least ZZ had the sense to admit that he has nothing "special", beyond what others have, as far as "interacting" with "God". Because I cornered him, he decided to admit that indeed God's existence cannot be proven. But he veiled that defeat by saying he's "not willing to go about proving the existence of God" Damage control and evasive maneuvers. So then, why bother keeping the myth alive? Anyway, that's pretty unfaithful, so to speak, coming from a presumably "born again"(whatever that means) evangelical Christian. Not much confidence in your God. _________________ Humans are the most vicious of all animal species.
And we still prey(sic)...
Does anyone ever listen?
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
agnos Currently banned Captain

 Joined: Dec 28, 2006 Posts: 629 Location: Canada
|
Posted: Sat Jun 02, 2007 9:46 am Post subject: |
|
|
| enegue wrote: | | Where are the numberless hymns, and poems, and essays, and treatises, and commentaries, analysing and disecting ENLIL's, and ENKI's record? |
enegue, let's be realistic here, those things are not "numberless". There are way more commentaries about sports every day in all the newspapers of the world and it does not mean anything except for just that... commentaries about sports. It does not mean that soccer and all the other sports are a religion for example, and Pele is not a God, though he sure played like one. You are trying to argue the existence of something by sheer volume of publications about that character. Universally, that has long been a flawed argument and has been debunked. I too, debunked it again, and easily.
Your argument can be applied to Islam also, and that does not mean that Islam is real, just because there are "numberless hymns, and poems, and essays, and treatises, and commentaries, analysing and disecting" the exploits of Allah and His "record".
You keep misusing the word "record", and it is not right. A record is something that can be verified and stored reliably. The religious texts do not fit this profile.
I told you, Homer's writings may contain some fairly reliable historical records, (according to the experts), but that does not mean his books are a "record" of Zeus and His exploits. So it is with the Bible and the Koran.
Don't you ever wonder why this supposed God of yours never shows up? In any way, shape or form? Nada? Except in a book and through "testimonials"? I told you, you can find plenty of people who think Elvis is alive too, just like you think Jesus is alive. And Elvis has one up on Jesus, because we can at least verify that Elvis really existed. NO one can verify that Jesus existed for sure. it's all second hand testimonials and word of mouth and hearsay. And even if he did exist, that does not imply that what a book says about him is real and true.
I'm sorry enegue, I know how hard this must be for you guys, but this is the reality that you must come to terms with. Or lie to yourself, if it makes you happy. And that's OK too, sometimes not knowing the truth can bring you more happiness and comfort. I don't want to take away your safety net and hope, but I am still searching, as a free spirit. And if you tag along with the truth diggers , you may not like what you find... _________________ Humans are the most vicious of all animal species.
And we still prey(sic)...
Does anyone ever listen?
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
agnos Currently banned Captain

 Joined: Dec 28, 2006 Posts: 629 Location: Canada
|
Posted: Sat Jun 02, 2007 9:52 am Post subject: |
|
|
I gotta stick a correction in there; it is still being debated within academia to what extent Homer was accurate, so I am not sure how he stacks up against the Bible. But it does not detract from my argument. _________________ Humans are the most vicious of all animal species.
And we still prey(sic)...
Does anyone ever listen?
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
agnos Currently banned Captain

 Joined: Dec 28, 2006 Posts: 629 Location: Canada
|
Posted: Sat Jun 02, 2007 7:30 pm Post subject: |
|
|
ZZ, we have a problem with "Ea", it turns out he also confused the languages of the Earth and He also had a flood story. That's where Noah's story comes from. I told you I was right. We must address this at some point. These are big problems. I told you you cannot dismiss the Ea/Enki source for the YHVH deity in the Old Testament. This is starting to look pretty suspect, don't you think? Everything started with Sumeria, like I said. Today we actually worship the Sumerian deities, but in a homogenized composite form purified through the spirit of Greek and Roman philosophy. I regret this, because if Christ is apparently not for real and the claims are bogus, we are all screwed. Oh, well, easy come come easy gone... Since there is no God, humanity had to invent Him, over and over again, and had to have Him die for us, because psychologically, it is the only way for us to attempt to patch the mortal wound that death inflicts on our psyche, emotions and our soul.
We had to adapt and evolve and deal with the damage death inflicts, and so we created yet another redemption scheme, in absence of the real thing. _________________ Humans are the most vicious of all animal species.
And we still prey(sic)...
Does anyone ever listen?
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
enegue
General
 Premium Member
 Joined: Aug 23, 2004 Posts: 3222 Location: Australia
|
Posted: Sat Jun 02, 2007 10:45 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Agnos wrote: | | The only thing I am pitting myself against is a fictional deity from a 2000 yrs old book, a composite entity from the ancient Pantheon of Gods. | Don't you see the absolute foolishness of this? Do you pit yourself against the easter bunny? What about the spaghetti monster? Are you contributing rapid fire, unrestrained posts to forums set up for the purpose of discussing their reality? Face it, you are haunted by a deity you don't even believe exists. A rational thinker would step back and see that this, in fact, makes the deity real. What a silly little man you've become.
| Agnos wrote: | Dude, your illogical logic scares me... What kind of thinking is this?
Enlil's and Enki's enemies do not exist, but Agnos exists, therefore YHVH must be the self-existing "One", (whatever that means), and therefore YHVH exists for real. | Clearly, I was too subtle. Try this then: You are his enemy (at this particular time), and believe it or not, you put meat on the bones of the serpent. Consider your message to the children of God? Isn't it the same as the serpent? Aren't you trying to sell us the same snake oil? You know, God is a liar, what He says won't happen, the best hope for achieving our potential is to ignore His instructions. If Yahweh didn't exist, then He would be as harmless as Enil and Enki, the easter bunny, and the spaghetti monster. He would have no enemies. You are living breathing proof that Yahweh is real.
Cheers,
enegue
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Wogdog
Colonel

 Joined: Feb 20, 2005 Posts: 2108
|
Posted: Sun Jun 03, 2007 12:02 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: | | What is behind the persistence of scripture? You have no explanation. | Fortuitous timing, Roman women, Constantine, big carrot, big stick.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
ZippyZingo
General
 Premium Member
 Joined: Apr 07, 2004 Posts: 3690 Location: USA
|
Posted: Sun Jun 03, 2007 1:05 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Agnos wrote: | | Sorry ZZ, that sounds like philosophy, not like religion. Religions have saviors(duh) or Gods. These people are not pushing any Gods. They were talking about God as a concept, not as a particular God. You are wrong. | I don't even know what you are writing about any more. I addressed your assertion, using your text reference. I just took what you presented and show you the truth of it. You can take or or leave it but you can't change it. What you said was clearly false.
You keep "saying" thing but you don't present any support that is worth anything. Like I keep telling you, I'm not going to take your word for it. I have no reason to accept anything just because you said so. You have no authority to back up your ideas.
| Agnos wrote: | | Reality is that which can be made evident and actively can be observed interacting with another element within reality. | This is an interesting definition, where did you get it?
By this definition, God must be real because I have prayed and received answers to my prayers. It has happened many more times than once AND has been repeated by many other people. God's answers to prayers have been "made evident" and God has been "actively observed interacting with another element within reality" by the many people that vouch for the power of prayer. All in all , your definition does what I have repeatedly said I have no intention of trying to do. You have managed to "prove" the existence of God.
Now, would you like to rethink your definition of should we run with it?
| Agnos wrote: | | Islam is just fine, and unfortunately overtaking Christianity by leaps and bounds. It is the fastest growing religion. | This is the second time you have brought this up but you have not produced a source for this. Show me where you got this.
| Agnos wrote: | | I have asked you to detail your supposed "relationship" to this entity, and you are unable to. | You confuse, "unable" with unwilling. Please note that it is comments exactly like this that make us "unwilling".
| Agnos wrote: | | At least ZZ had the sense to admit that he has nothing "special", beyond what others have, as far as "interacting" with "God". Because I cornered him, he decided to admit that indeed God's existence cannot be proven. But he veiled that defeat by saying he's "not willing to go about proving the existence of God" | You make me tired and you make me think it is senseless to try to communicate with you. It has always been my position that I cannot and will not try to prove God exist. I posted that position LONG before you arrived. There was no "corner ". The fact is that what you said is inaccurate bordering on a lie. I never said that God's existence "cannot be prove", only that I cannot prove it. I also noticed that you are STILL unable to accurately quote me about "special access". What is the point of this?? Do you imagine that it somehow makes you right? I don't get it. Why post something you must know is a false?
You are VERY careless with other people's words. Next time you "quote" me, please QUOTE me or leave me out of your post. I'm very tired of correcting you. There is nothing to be gained in this tactic and it doesn't take long to go from "mistake" to a lie. Remember when we were talking about "respect" and I said I didn't see a lot coming from you? This is what I was talking about ?
| Agnos wrote: | | ZZ, we have a problem with "Ea", it turns out he also confused the languages of the Earth and He also had a flood story. That's where Noah's story comes from. I told you I was right. | I'm sorry, what about this makes you "right"? I don't even know what I'm supposed to address here. You presented some opinions out of nowhere and claimed victory.
If your looking at the material on the "personalpages" link, forget it, there is nothing "authoritative" about it. It's just some guy that think like you do. For all I know, it IS you. I just have no way of knowing. It doesn't mean anything that you found someone else that thinks as you do.
Are you thinking that you are "right" because there is a flood story or a "Babel" story? Those stories are found around the world. For "Ea" to be responsible for it, this god would have had to be worshiped in the Islands of the pacific and in South America too. In fact, there are a lot of different stories and belief found around the world that echo what is found in the Bible. These things are found in places that could not possibly have influenced the Biblical writers yet they are there. Why is that? Perhaps because it spells out clearly what other cultures only remember dimly?
ZZ
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
agnos Currently banned Captain

 Joined: Dec 28, 2006 Posts: 629 Location: Canada
|
Posted: Sun Jun 03, 2007 1:12 am Post subject: |
|
|
| enegue wrote: | | You are living breathing proof that Yahweh is real |
Dude, you have clearly lost it... That's all I can say. _________________ Humans are the most vicious of all animal species.
And we still prey(sic)...
Does anyone ever listen?
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Wogdog
Colonel

 Joined: Feb 20, 2005 Posts: 2108
|
Posted: Sun Jun 03, 2007 1:32 am Post subject: |
|
|
| enegue wrote: | | You are living breathing proof that Yahweh is real. | Then you must be living, breathing proof that evolution is real. No, wait....
(Sorry, E, I couldn't resist.)
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
agnos Currently banned Captain

 Joined: Dec 28, 2006 Posts: 629 Location: Canada
|
Posted: Sun Jun 03, 2007 1:51 am Post subject: |
|
|
ZZ, EVERYTHING in the Bible, Do you hear what I am saying to you? [b]Everything in it, in terms of religious motifs, appears in much older mythologies. Can you process this reality, or will you spin and rationalize forever? Do you have any idea that there is nothing original in the Bible? The human writers of the Bible plagiarized earlier myths, and nothing you ever say and nothing you ever spin will change that truth[/b]. _________________ Humans are the most vicious of all animal species.
And we still prey(sic)...
Does anyone ever listen?
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
agnos Currently banned Captain

 Joined: Dec 28, 2006 Posts: 629 Location: Canada
|
Posted: Sun Jun 03, 2007 2:02 am Post subject: |
|
|
Oh, Wog, I feel like laughing so hard, but when I realize how sad this is, it makes me feel regret and sorrow that anyone can be this brainwashed, and that sobers me up, and I feel compassion. This is beyond stubborness, and beyond fanaticism, it's complete renunciation of one's logical faculties, and no amount of hard evidence will change the victim's mind. It's an altered state no different than the psychotic alternate realities that invade the minds of those who harbor them in a virtual "Jim Jones land" and who are not aware that their delusions have no basis in reality. It's basically very similar to schizophrenia, in terms of vividness and obsessive persistence as a usurper of the actual reality system of reference. I cannot reason with the dissolution of reason itself. _________________ Humans are the most vicious of all animal species.
And we still prey(sic)...
Does anyone ever listen?
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
agnos Currently banned Captain

 Joined: Dec 28, 2006 Posts: 629 Location: Canada
|
Posted: Sun Jun 03, 2007 2:09 am Post subject: |
|
|
| ZZ wrote: | Agnos wrote:
Reality is that which can be made evident and actively can be observed interacting with another element within reality.
This is an interesting definition, where did you get it? |
I got it from reality. And it's the definition of what's real. Anything that does not fit my definition is not real, until it can be observed to satisfy my definition.
If you deny the truth of my definition, than you are not steeped in reality, and that falls into the realm and diagnosis of a whole new discipline with which we are all familiar with. So I hope you won't go there. For the sake of your reputation and balance. _________________ Humans are the most vicious of all animal species.
And we still prey(sic)...
Does anyone ever listen?
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
enegue
General
 Premium Member
 Joined: Aug 23, 2004 Posts: 3222 Location: Australia
|
Posted: Sun Jun 03, 2007 2:19 am Post subject: |
|
|
I don't think you've caught the drift of what I am saying, Wog. I am not the enemy of evolution. I don't spend hours composing arguments to try to convince people not to believe in evolution. In fact I believe in the scientific aspects of evolution, and I have argued in the past that the faith-based aspects should be taken out of the science classroom and included with religion as studies in philosophy. I am happy for people to consider the alternatives.
Wog, there is an obvious difference between holding up an alternative way of thinking, which I do, and an all out effort to destroy something that doesn't exist, which is what Agnos is doing. Agnos is not a fool, and the truth is He doesn't think he is wasting his time. He has jumped on a bandwaggon that rises and falls through the ages, but the Gospel continues to grow, and prosper.
Cheers,
enegue
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum You cannot attach files in this forum You can download files in this forum
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001 phpBB Group
|